Since the transition to color TV in the 1950s and ’60s, nothing -
nothing!! - has had as much impact on the TV world as HDTV
(high-definition TV) and digital TV. That’s right, TV is going digital,
following in the footsteps of, well, everything.
We’re in the early days of this transition - a lot of TV programming
is still all-analog, for example - and this stage of the game can be
confusing. In this article, we alleviate HDTV anxiety by telling you
what you need to know about HDTV, ATSC, DTV, and a bunch of
other acronyms and tech terms. We also tell you why you’d want to
know these terms and concepts - how great HDTV is, and what an
improvement it is over today’s analog TV (as you’ll see when you
tune in to HDTV). Finally, we guide you through the confusing back
alleys of HDTV and digital TV - making sure you know what’s
HDTV and what’s not.
Oh, Say, Can You ATSC?
A long time ago (over 50 years ago - longer than even Danny
has been alive!), in a galaxy far, far . . . errr, actually right here in
the U.S. . . . a group called the NTSC (National Television System
Committee) put together a group of technical specifications and
standards that define television as we know it today. Sure, there
have been some changes in those 50 years (such as the addition
of color), but today’s analog TVs are built on this NTSC system.
Fifty years is a long time for any technology to dominate. Indeed,
technologies and components used in television-transmission systems, cameras, recording systems, and display systems (the TVs
themselves) have long been capable of doing something more.
In the 1980s, the ATSC (Advanced Television System Committee)
was formed to move TV forward.
Many years later (1996), the
ATSC’s recommendations for a digital-television system were
adopted by the FCC (Federal Communications Commission - the
folks who set standards for TV broadcasts, regulate phone companies,
and fine Howard Stern). ATSC standards use newer-than-1953
technology to give you TV like you’ve never had before:
- Widescreen images like those in the movies
- Greater detail - up to six times more detail
- Sharper images
- Smoother, more filmlike images with no video flicker
- All digital, with none of the “ghosts” and other image problems
found in analog TV
Powerful Performance
HDTV (and digital TV, DTV, in general - there are some digital TV
variants that are not high-definition, and we discuss them in this
section) is all about giving you a bigger and better picture, better
audio, and generally making your TV-watching experience more
like a movie-watching experience. In fact, at its best, HDTV is so
realistic that it’s often described as “looking through a window” -
as if you’re really there, not just watching a program.
Video standards
There are three essential concepts to understand when you are
comparing different video standards:
- Resolution: the number of individual picture elements that
make up a TV image. The higher the resolution, the more
detailed the image, and the sharper the image will appear.
Resolution is defined by one of two factors:
• Lines (the number of left-to-right lines the TV can display).
CRT-based TVs (tube TVs) are rated this way.
• Pixels (the number of pixels across the screen times the
number up and down). Fixed-pixel displays (plasmas,
LCDs, DLPs and the like) are rated this way.
- Scan Type comes in two forms:
• Interlaced scan: These TV images are created by lighting
up every other row of horizontal lines on the screen in
one instant, and then going back through and lighting up
the remainder of the lines in the next instant. It happens
so fast that your eye can’t really tell it’s happening.
• Progressive scan: These systems light all the horizontal
lines in the same instant, which can make the image
seem “smoother” and more like film (or real life).
- Aspect Ratio (the shape of your TV picture):
• Traditional TVs have a 4:3 aspect ratio (screen shape).
This means that for every 4 units of measure across the
screen, you have 3 units of screen height. For example, if
the screen is 12 inches wide, it will be 9 inches high.
• HDTVs have a 16:9 aspect ratio - which makes the
screen relatively much wider for the same height, compared
to a 4:3 TV. Most movies are widescreen (16:9, or
even wider), so HDTVs can display most movies without
the annoying “letterbox” black bars on the top and
bottom of the screen.
We don’t get bogged down in up-front technical explanations of
these concepts. If you want to know all there is to know about such
TV concepts as resolution, pixels, and interlacing, run (don’t walk)
to Article 21 right now. We’ll still be here when you come back.
HDTV standards
There isn’t a single “HDTV” standard out there. Instead, ATSC
contains many different TV standards (with different resolutions,
aspect ratios, and scan types) - 18, in fact. Some of these standards
are truly HDTV; most are not. In the real world, you will deal with
four standards when you try to watch TV content on your HDTV.
The two primary HDTV standards are these:
- 720p: This provides 720 lines of resolution with progressive
scan (hence the p). By comparison, NTSC has less than 480
lines of resolution. 720p uses a 16:9, a widescreen aspect ratio.
- 1080i: This variant (the highest resolution within the ATSC
standard) uses interlaced scanning, but provides 1080 lines of
resolution. 1080i is also widescreen, with a 16:9 aspect ratio.
There is actually a higher HDTV variant in the ATSC standard -
1080p, which is a progressive scan variant of 1080i. Only a few
HDTV projectors (in the $40,000 and above price range) can handle
this variant, and we know of no material that is broadcast or otherwise
available as 1080p. So don’t worry about it.
True HDTV performance requires at least 720p performance. If a
TV program, movie, or other content is not at least 720p (either
720p or 1080i), it is not HDTV. If a TV can’t display at least 720 lines
of resolution, it is not HDTV-capable.
If a salesperson tries to tell you that an inexpensive plasma set,
regular DVD, regular digital cable, or regular satellite TV “is” HDTV
just because it’s digital, it’s not so.
Compatible DTV standards
720p and 1080i are the two HDTV standards, but you’ll also find a
lot of digital TV material will be broadcast at lower resolutions that
don’t quite make the grade as HDTV. You can still watch this programming
on your HDTV - in fact, most HDTVs will make this
programming look better than it does on a regular TV - but
remember: That stuff is not really HDTV.
- 480p (EDTV): This enhanced-definition TV standard provides
higher-than-NTSC resolution, with progressive scan (NTSC is
interlaced). EDTV can be (and often is) 16:9 widescreen, but it
is not required to be widescreen.
- 480i (SDTV): This is interlaced, non-widescreen (4:3), standarddefinition
TV, equivalent to NTSC analog broadcasts.
Remember these different terms - HDTV, EDTV, and SDTV - when
shopping. They will often be in the product descriptions; you need
to know exactly what you are buying.
Audio standards
The ATSC standard includes big improvements in the audio part
of television - what you hear as part of any movie, video, or TV
show. That’s because ATSC includes Dolby Digital surround sound
capability in the overall standard for digital TV.
Dolby Digital (which we discuss in greater detail in Article 18)
doesn’t always mean surround sound. Some Dolby Digital soundtracks
are stereo (two channels) or even mono (one channel).
ATSC supports surround sound if a program’s producer and broadcaster
want to include it.
The NTSC broadcast standard supports only stereo audio (two
channels) and not surround sound. Luckily, most DVDs (and some
satellite and digital cable TV channels) include Dolby Digital
soundtracks that can provide true surround sound. You can also
use a home-theater receiver that supports systems like Dolby
Pro Logic II (see Article 18) to create surround sound from
these sources.
Dolby Digital, and surround sound in general, provides an audio
soundtrack for TV shows and movies that - wait for it! - surrounds you and provides audio that matches the action on-screen. For
example, surround sound might use speakers mounted in the rear
of the room to reproduce ambient noises of the setting around the
action, or give a 3D sense of space to those creepy footfalls of the
bad guy sneaking up behind the protagonist.
Dolby Digital provides six channels (confusingly called 5.1) of
audio. Here’s what they do:
- A center channel carries the dialogue being spoken by characters
on your HDTV screen.
- Two main front channels handle left and right sound cues
(and the soundtrack music) in stereo.
- Two surround channels (mounted in the rear of the room,
as described earlier) provide a sense of 3D space.
- A Low-Frequency Effects (LFE) channel conveys deep bass
sounds (such as exhausts rumbling and bombs exploding).
The LFE channel is the “.1” in the 5.1 naming scheme for
Dolby Digital. It doesn’t get a whole number because it contains
only low-frequency sounds, not the full range of human
hearing.
Perplexing Pitfalls
HDTV isn’t the easiest thing in the world to get figured out - we’ve
been dealing with it for years and still run into advertising and
marketing mumbo-jumbo that make us say, “Huh???” The whole
purpose of HDTV For Dummies is to help you wade through the
marketing manure and to get you up to speed on HDTV. So without
further ado, here’s a list of HDTV danger zones:
- Digital confusion: The biggest (and most prevalent) myth we
see in the HDTV world is the notion that any kind of digital TV
signal (such as digital cable, digital satellite, or DVD) is HDTV.
This simply isn’t true - a TV signal must be 720p resolution
or higher to be considered high-definition.
- EDTV confusion: EDTVs are TVs (typically plasma flat-panel
models) that cost a lot and can display progressive-scan
images - but don’t meet the minimum requirement of 720p,
so they don’t display true HDTV signals. There’s nothing
wrong with EDTVs, just don’t be fooled into thinking you’re
getting an HDTV when you’re not.
- Image scaling: We’re starting to see some new marketing
being applied to an old concept - image scalers that can convert
video signals from one resolution to another.
These devices are now being marketed as “HDTV upscalers”
(yeah right), with a promise that they make any TV signal into
HDTV. Don’t believe it. Image scalers can improve SDTV and
NTSC images with an HDTV, but they don’t make those images into HDTV images.
- The DTV tuner: As HDTV (and DTV in general) becomes more
prevalent, DTV tuners will become common. These tuners
(discussed in Article 8) let older TVs “watch” DTV broadcasts.
DTV tuners do not turn older analog TVs into HDTVs.
They just convert DTV signals to NTSC for display on an
analog TV. Shopping Smart We’ve all been there - you’re standing in the electronics store
looking at a wall of TVs, all tuned to the same channel, and
they all pretty much look the same. So many TV sets, so little time,
so hard to choose. So you pick the one on sale and leave, happy
that you got “a deal.” Been there, done that.
But no more. Now we’re more educated. We KNOW that those TV
sets are all misconfigured to appear a certain way in the bright lights
of an electronics show floor. We know to check how many digital
interfaces the box has, and how deep the chassis is, and how . . .
well, lots of “hows.”
Choosing the right HDTV for you is not the easiest thing to do.
Heck, we wrote the article on it and we still argue with each other
about which HDTVs have the best bang for the buck. It’s going to
depend on what you are trying to do, how much money you have,
and what other A/V gear you have or intend to buy.
In this article, we’re going to walk you through a veritable Buyer’s
Guide to HDTVs - what to look for when shopping for just the right
HDTV set for you. You can have too much HDTV (believe it or not)
and the wrong type of TV for your intended use.
Before you plunk
down a lot of money on your well-earned HDTV surprise, make sure
you’re the best- informed buyer out there. Read on.
The 50,000-Foot View of HDTV
When you’re trying to pick out the right HDTV for your needs, the
available products break down into three major product groups,
distinguished from each other by their display technology and cabinet
type. By comparing display technology and cabinet type to
your needs, you can easily rule out a whole bunch of different TVs,
and home in on the likely best ones for you.
HDTVs come in all sorts of different sizes and shapes. Some are
flat-panels that you can hang on the wall; others are projection
systems much like what you’d find in a movie theater. And, of
course, there are HDTVs based on tubes that look just the way
TVs have for decades (only with a better picture).
Each form of HDTV has some advantages and disadvantages. In
Articles 21 through 24, we discuss these pros and cons in much
more detail - here we want to give you just a quick overview to
help you on your way. Skip ahead if you need the details and supporting
information.
Flat-panel HDTVs
Flat-panel TVs - the super-thin models that you can literally hang
on the wall - are the sexiest HDTVs available. These are the ones
you see on MTV Cribs and that you might install in your tricked-out
Escalade (yeah right). They’re also good HDTVs. There are two
main display technologies for flat-panel HDTVs:
- Plasma: These are the biggest flat-screens available, using a
layer of gas trapped between two glass screens to create their
images.
• Pros: thin, sexy, good picture, good color
• Cons: not all are HDTV, less-than-perfect black, screen
burn-in, costly
You’ll see us mention “blacks” here. We’re talking about
how well an HDTV screen can reproduce dark tones and
scenes on-screen - how well it creates black rather
than gray colors.
- LCD: These flat-panel TVs use liquid crystal displays, just like
those used in laptop computers.
• Pros: same as plasma, plus no burn-in
• Cons: black is poorest, costly, angle of view
Projection HDTVs
These are the TVs that project their picture from a smaller image
source (either three small picture tubes, or a digital system known
as a microprojector) onto a screen. The screen can be either part of
the HDTV itself (rear projection) or a separate screen hung on your
wall (front projection).
- Front-Projection HDTVs: These are the HDTV equivalents to
movie theater projectors, with a big screen on the wall, and a
separate projector mounted somewhere across the room.
• Pros: biggest screen, potentially best picture
• Con: expensive, complicated, requires setup/focus/
maintenance
- Rear projection HDTVs: The picture is projected on the back
of a screen that is built into the HDTV itself.
• Pros: best bargain, no burn-in with microprojectors,
near flat-panel thinness for microprojector
• Cons: burn-in for CRT, expense for microprojector, size
for CRT
CRT HDTVs
The final category of HDTVs is based on the good old-fashioned
picture tube - also known as the CRT, or cathode-ray tube.
- Pros: cheapest, great color, great blacks
- Cons: smallest screen, bulky, lower resolution than digital
displays
What’s Important in an HDTV
When looking at HDTVs, we think the following are the most important
buying criteria for your purchase:
- What’s your budget? We don’t mean just for the TV set, but
also for any attached home theater surround-sound system,
special remote controls, automated drapes, lighting controls,
popcorn poppers, and the like. It makes a big difference if you
are building a home HDTV theater, or just putting a TV on the
bureau in the bedroom.
- What size do you need? No, bigger is not always better. You
can have a TV that’s too large for your space, or too small for your usage. There is an optimal range based on where you
intend to place the TV and where you intend to sit.
These first two items - size and budget - will do a lot to
narrow your choices before you get to any of the technical or
usage criteria, so they are important to nail down first. If you
want to fill an 8-foot wall with an image, unless you have a
bank account the size of Bill Gates’s, you’re not going to do
that with anything but a front-projection system.
- What do you plan to do with it? Are you going to be watching
a lot of sports events? Movies? Video games? Believe it or not,
certain types of HDTVs are better with certain types of content.
Sports fanatics will find a big, bright DLP projection
system better for their tastes, everything else being equal,
while people who watch CNN all day long will want to avoid
plasma-screen displays in a big way, due to the burn-in effects
of static images (more on this later).
- What will you hook up to it? If you already have a decent
investment in A/V gear, then that gear might dictate certain
types (and numbers!) of interfaces or ports on your HDTV
system, like these:
• If you have an entertainment system designed around
centralized video switching - using a receiver to switch
among video sources and destinations - then you’re
going to need a receiver that can switch HDTV content.
That might mean a new receiver, which can be pricey
and cut into your budget.
• Do you need a tuner or just an HDTV-ready display -
meaning you’ll get your HDTV tuner from your cable or
satellite company?
- What neat features do you want? It’s easy to be swayed by
neat features, but in lots of implementations, you can’t access
them for various reasons. For instance, if you set up your
system so all your signals come in over one cable connection,
you might not be able to use your TV’s dual-channel features -
you could rely on your cable or satellite box for that. (We talk
about these issues in Article 4.) Still, features are important
to all of us, and we’ll tell you in this article about which ones
are the most important.
Budgeting for HDTV
If we all had unlimited funds, we’d simply buy the best of everything.
That’s why there exists a market for super-high-end gear - those with the big bucks often just buy the top of the line all the time,
because they can. (And because they hired consultants to tell
them that.)
Finding the Right Size
We think it’s an outright crime that movie theaters can sell tickets
for those rows up at the front of the cinema, where your head has
to constantly move back and forth (like at a tennis match) to capture
all the action. Likewise, the seats far away at the back are just
as criminal.
So apply that principle to your home HDTV viewing area. You can
be too close to the image (or have the image too large), and you
can be too far away (or have the image too small). You definitely
know you are too close if you can see the individual pixels on the
screen.
What you need is “Baby Bear’s Just Right” size.
In general, experts determine the optimal size for your HDTV set
by dividing the distance you are going to sit from the TV set by 2.5
(don’t ask us where they got that number, we haven’t a clue - we
bet by trial and error - actually there’s a lot of science regarding
such technically arcane items as the size of pixels and the average
person’s visual acuity. You really don’t want to know!).
Matching Your HD Needs
You need to match how you intend to use the HDTV with the available
technologies. While any HDTV type can be used for just about
any TV viewing scenario you can think of, certain types of HDTV
are better suited for particular uses. This is basically a technical
issue - different types of HDTVs use different underlying technologies
to create their pictures - which often match up better
with some uses than with others.
For instance, if you pack a lot of friends into a wide room to watch
movies a lot, you may want to consider a plasma or direct-view CRT
(a tube HDTV) display, instead of a CRT rear-projection TV or LCD
flat-panel. That’s because plasma and direct-view CRTs have the
best viewing angle (viewing from the sides).
Connecting the Other Gizmos
Your HDTV doesn’t live in a vacuum.
|