Taping Time In our collective rush to sift through the $5 DVD bins at Wal-
Mart, it’s easy to overlook the good ol’ VCR that sits precariously
atop many of our TV sets at home. DVDs are cooler, packed
with more data, and they’re . . . well . . . digital.
But almost all of us have a lot of investment in the VCR — ranging
from the scores of VHS files purchased over the years, to the
recorded broadcast and home movies that make up our VHS collections.
It may not be a big investment, dollarwise, but we often
have an emotional investment in those old tapes! Even in the face
of several generations of higher-quality video options — laser disc,
DVDs, satellite, and now HDTV and DVRs — it’s hard to part with
our dependable VHS VCR.
That’s because the venerable VCR is simply a useful device — and
it has even been remaking itself for this new, high-definition world.
In this article, we talk about how to get your old VCR hooked up
to your HDTV so you can dust off those old taped episodes of LA
Law (you ’80s fan, you!); we also discuss some of the (few) new digital
VCR models hitting the market that you might want to investigate
to upgrade your taping capabilities.
Checking Out Your Digital Options
If you stroll into your neighborhood electronics store, or surf for
VCRs online, you’ll see three kinds of VCRs available today:
- VHS VCRs: Familiar to all, these are the standard VCRs you’ve
seen in stores for almost 30 years. These VCRs use VHS videocassettes
and record a low-resolution TV signal — about 240
lines of resolution (a third of the 720 lines you get with HDTV!).
These VHS VCRs can come cheap (less than $50) or expensive
(more than $800); most include stereo audio capabilities (if
so, they’re labeled HiFi) and analog Dolby surround-sound
capabilities.
- S-VHS VCRs: The S-VHS (or Super VHS) VCR provides a
higher-quality, higher-resolution image — 400 lines, instead of
about 240. In the midst of the craze for more resolution, you’d
be forgiven for guessing that film buffs would have jumped at
the first S-VHS VCRs back when they were introduced, but
they’ve been slow to take off, for several reasons:
• With the early models, you had to buy more expensive
(and harder-to-find), specialized tapes to record in S-VHS
mode.
• You can’t play an S-VHS tape in a regular VCR (but you
can do the reverse).
• S-VHS VCRs themselves have been significantly pricier
than the standard-format VCRs on the market.
• There were very few prerecorded movies available in the
S-VHS format.
Lately, however, S-VHS VCRs have made a bit of a comeback,
driven by lower equipment pricing — S-VHS VCRs start off
at around $120 — and a new technology boost in the form
of S-VHS-ET (Expansion Technology), introduced by JVC.
S-VHS-ET allows an S-VHS VCR to record a full S-VHS signal on
regular VHS tape. There’s also the fact that higher-resolution
source material from camcorders, satellite and digital cable
transmission — and the ensuing display of recorded tapes
on higher-definition displays — have raised the bar for video
recorders as well. (You really notice poor resolution when it’s
50 inches and 1280 x 720 in front of you!)
There’s very little difference in pricing between a high-quality
VHS VCR and an S-VHS VCR (really cheap VHS VCRs are a lot
cheaper, of course). If you’re already spending 100 bucks or so
for a hi-fi VCR, we think you should find the extra $20 to get
into an S-VHS model.
You’ll also find a few VCRs on the market that are labled
“Quasi-SVHS”. These units will play back S-VHS tapes, but only
at the lower VHS resolution. They’re handy if you don’t care
about the higher resolution, but have some S-VHS (or S-VHS-C
camcorder) tapes that you want to watch.
- D-VHS VCRs: If you’re going whole-hog high-def, then you
want to look at a high-definition VCR — specifically, the D-VHS
VCR. D-VHS VCRs can play and record standard VHS and S-VHS
formats. More importantly D-VHS VCRs can also record and
play back in all the HDTV formats (discussed in Article 21),
including 1080i, 720p, 480p, and 480i.
To record and play back HDTV, the D-VHS system needs an
FireWire (also called i.LINK or IEEE 1394) connector to connect
to an HDTV TV or a standalone HDTV tuner. Many HDTVs
and HDTV tuners don’t have a FireWire connection, however,
because broadcasters and movie studios don’t want you to be
able to record HDTV programs. So be sure of your connection
options before plunking down the cash for a D-VHS VCR.
The D-VHS VCR sounds like a great idea — and indeed, if you
tape a lot, this might be the VCR for you. However, you’re
probably going to be disappointed with its use on a day-to-day
basis, for a couple of reasons:
• D-VHS would be pretty cool, if many people weren’t
restricted from using it for its intended purpose —
recording HDTV shows for later playback. Unfortunately,
there’s a fundemental disconnect between the HDTV
connection provided on D-VHS decks (FireWire), and
that found on the majority of HDTV tuners/set-top boxes
(DVI).
• There are only limited number of movies available on
prerecorded D-VHS videocassettes — truly a small
number (less than a hundred) compared to what you
can get on DVD (tens of thousands).
Many people who used to use VCRs a lot are focusing on DVRs
(see Article 12) or are using DVDs, particularly as HDTV-capable
DVD formats are being announced and heading to market (see
Article 11). As a result, D-VHS VCRs have not really taken the
market by storm — and really dropped in price recently as a
result (they can be had for about $600). The D-VHS VCR category
is largely heading for Laserdisc status (that is, dead), or at least
confined to a niche market of D-VHS enthusiasts.
What will really nail the coffin of the D-VHS system is the advent of
HDTV-capable DVD systems — particularly when these offer
recording capability to users. Combine a high-def DVR with a
recordable Blu-ray DVD system and you have the best of all
worlds. No tapes to mess with, just pure, digital, skip-right-towhere-
you-want-to-be-without-rewinding bliss.
Given that this is a article on HDTV and not on VCRs (and that the
main high-definition angle to VCRs is D-VHS), we’re going to spend
the rest of this article talking about how to hook up your VCR
into your HDTV system for best viewing. We also look at one of the
only D-VHS products actually on the market as we write. If you
want to know more about VCRs in general, try checking out
http://hometheater.about.com.
Connecting VCRs to HDTVs
You often have a choice of connections/cable types to use when
connecting source devices (such as VCRs) to your HDTV (Article 3
covers the details). Choosing which of these connections to use can
be (initially) a bit confusing, but they fall into a hierarchy — and
when you get a handle on that, matters get easier: Just pick the best
connection option available on both ends of the connection.
When it comes to VCR connection options, we can make it even
easier for you. You have three choices, depending on what kind of
VCR you own:
- Connecting VHS VCRs: If you have a VHS VCR (not an S-VHS
model), you have only two choices — you can connect using a
composite video cable (and a pair of audio cables), or you can
use the coaxial cable output of the VCR. We recommend that
you use the composite video cable — it delivers a much
better picture than coaxial cable.
- Connecting S-VHS VCRs: These VCRs add an S-video connector
(that’s where the name came from originally — even though
S-video connections are now found on DVD players, set-top
boxes, game consoles, and other source devices). S-video provides
a much better picture than composite video, so use this
connection (and a pair of audio cables) to connect your S-VHS
videocassette recorder.
- Connecting a D-VHS VCR: You need to use component video
cables to get HDTV signals into an HDTV display. So it should
come as no surprise that the preferred connection method for the HDTV-capable D-VHS VCR is a triumvirate (yep, there’s a
troika — three — of them) of component video cables. You’ll
also want to use a digital audio cable (optical or coaxial) to
take advantage of the digital surround-sound signals recorded
on D-VHS high-definition recordings.
If you don’t use the component video cable, you can’t view
HDTV recordings in high definition.
In addition to these “playback” connections, which enable you to
view videocassettes played on your VCR, you’ll also want to make
a “recording” connection between your TV source and your VCR.
Your options are many, and depend greatly on a whole host of variables
regarding what else you’ve connected to your HDTV (and
how it’s connected). Here are some general rules to follow:
- If you have a D-VHS deck, and you want to record in HDTV, the
answer is simple. You need to connect your HDTV tuner to the
D-VHS using the FireWire (or iLINK) cable. There is no other
option — which severely limits the usefulness of the D-VHS,
as few HDTV tuners have functioning FireWire connections
that will make this work.
- For a non-HDTV VCR recording, your options depend on two
things: whether you’ve connected a home-theater receiver as
part of your overall HDTV home-theater system, and whether
you require a set-top box or satellite receiver for non-DTV TV
channels.
• If you’re using a home-theater receiver (discussed
in Article 19), take advantage of this device’s videoswitching
capabilities. You can connect all your video
source devices (such as DVD players, cable set-top
boxes, and satellite receivers) into a set of inputs on
the receiver. Then you can use the outputs on the back
of the receiver to connect both your HDTV (for viewing)
and your VCR (for recording). This is the best, and most
flexible, way of connecting your VCR for recording.
• If you don’t have a home-theater receiver, you have to
connect your VCR inline between your TV source and
your HDTV. This could be as simple as plugging an
antenna cable into the back of your VCR (to the TV In
connection) and then using another antenna cable
(coaxial cable) to connect the TV Out jack on your VCR
to the Antenna input on your VCR. If you have a set-top
box or satellite receiver, you need an extra set of S-video
or composite-video cables to make this connection.
Looking Closer at D-VHS
So if you have high-definition leanings (and why else would you be
reading HDTV For Dummies?), you at least owe it to yourself to consider
whether a D-VHS will work for you. So . . .
- Here’s what you can expect to do with it:
• Record over-the-air broadcasts
• Watch D-VHS prerecorded tapes
• Store HDTV camcorder content to D-VHS
- Here’s what you may not be able to do with it:
• Record cable or satellite broadcasts (many set-top
boxes lack a FireWire port to send digital signals to the
D-VHS, due to copyright concerns — and some that do
have the capability don’t have it enabled by software, so
it’s a useless connection that won’t work).
- Here’s what you can’t do with it:
• Make tapes of your favorite Hollywood DVD movies.
(A copy-protection system called Macrovision keeps you
from doing so, and it’s built into all DVDs and all VCRs.
Even if you want to copy your favorite movie from DVD
to VHS to play back on a VCR in your vacation home or
somewhere else, you’re just plain out of luck.)
If these benefits and limitations seem reasonable to you, then consider
getting a D-VHS VCR. When it comes to playing and recording
high-def signals, you have to go D-VHS or you’re simply not getting
all you can out of your HDTV lifestyle! No other format can match
those high-res images, baby . . .
. . . at least not yet. When high-def DVD discs and players hit the
market (and they’ve been announced as we write, but can’t be
bought in stores yet), their resolutions will equal those of D-VHS.
The D-VHS VCRs use high-capacity D-VHS tapes to record HDTV
broadcasts at their full resolution. They can upconvert or downconvert
HD recordings on playback to match your TV’s display
rate (even when connected to a regular analog TV).
D-VHS VCRs typically can do some other hand things:
- Record/play Digital VHS, Super VHS, Super VHS ET, and standard
VHS formats
- Store (on one DF-420 D-VHS tape) up to 3.5 hours of material
in HS mode (28.2 Mbps), 7 hours in STD mode (14.1 Mbps),
21 hours in LS3 mode (4.7 Mbps) or 35 hours in LS5 mode
(2.8 Mbps)
The higher the bit rate (the preceding Mbps numbers) the less
compressed the video is, and the better it looks.
- Record/play at 1080i, 720p, 480p, and 480i resolutions
- Record/play 5.1-channel Dolby Digital and DTS HDTV broadcasts
for surround sound
- Play HiFi stereo VHS and S-VHS for Dolby Pro Logic surround
sound
You’ll find some other VCR features from regular VHS/S-VHS VCRs
that you might recognize. For example, you might find VCR Plus+,
which allows an average human being to record a certain show at
a certain time more easily. With this system, all you have to do is
punch in a special code that is listed next to the show you want to
record in your paper’s TV listings (or in TV Guide). More advanced
versions of VCR Plus+ (called Silver and Gold) allow you to localize
your VCR Plus+ settings for your area.
VCR Plus+ is handy, but once you’ve used a slick DVR interface
(such as TiVo’s), you’ll never want to go back to using even the
finest VCR system! Of course, you can only record HDTV on a TiVo
if you buy a $1,000 DirecTV TiVo system.
At the time of this writing, we could only find one or two D-VHS
products left on the market (and we looked a lot!). The most popular
and prominent is JVC’s HM-DH4000U. As an indication
of the market acceptance of D-VHS thus far, the list price for
JVC’s only D-VHS model (and JVC invented/promoted the D-VHS!) is
$999.95, but you can get it at Crutchfield (which has competitive but
not hugely discounted prices) for $599.99 — 40 percent off! So if you
want one, we’d advise you to move quickly, because these might not
be around much longer.
Monitor Madness
Who said HDTVs had to be all about watching DVDs
and high-definition satellite signals? We sure didn’t.
In fact, there are all sorts of other ways to get high-definition
signals on and off your HD system — so many that we
created this special part to talk about them.
We’ll discuss all the high-definition implications of your
PS2, Xbox, Nintendo, or other gaming console, including
noting which consoles allow you to play DVDs on your
HDTV. (Now, that’s double duty.)
For example, we’ll talk about what to do with your camcorder
if you want to view your home movies in 1280-x-
720-pixel mode (and what to think about when you crave a
new high-definition camcorder for those really fine-looking
shots of your kids in pumpkin-head Halloween outfits).
Then the fun really begins, as we discuss the wide range of
gadgets that are popping up to accentuate your HDTV purchase.
We’ll talk about souped-up PCs designed to support
your HDTV-powered home theater, video jukeboxes that
make watching another movie truly point-and-click, and
how to take a bath with your HDTV (shocking isn’t it . . .
oh, bad pun!).
We wrap with a discussion of how to take advantage of
your HDTV from all over the home, with tips, tricks and
guidance on home networking. Pat and Danny wrote the
article on this, well, actually two articles — Smart Homes For
Dummies and Wireless Home Networking For Dummies —
so you get a great introduction to how to access HDTV in
a whole-home way.
|