God Bosses enjoy the performance review process because it gives
them the opportunity to let you know how much you have pleased or
displeased them during the preceding year. To a God Boss, a good
employee genuflects. As long as the team member being reviewed
spends sufficient time on bended knee worshiping the God Boss and
presents suitable tithes and offerings, the review will be positive,
regardless of whether or not anything is getting accomplished in the
department.
To prepare for a performance review with a God Boss, choose
your wardrobe carefully. Sackcloth and sandals might be appropriate.
Perhaps a prayer shawl for the men and a Khimar for the ladies. Your
clothing should reflect humility and submissiveness. God Bosses take
themselves very seriously. The more ceremony you engage in the better.
Burning incense and chanting his name are nice touches. Be careful
though. Pay attention and determine what will be an adequate demonstration
of your devotion without going over the top. God Bosses
don't appreciate being mocked.
For your best shot at getting a raise from a God Boss, use terms
like "your greatness," "your majesty," and "your lordship," throughout
the year. It all sounds blasphemous because it is, but do you want
the raise or not? And don't worry about the true God feeling mocked.
The sight of the whole thing probably has Him on the floor. No matter
how literally you take your God Boss, always refer to his accomplishments,
his glory, and his mighty power when talking business or golf.
Go with the flow on this one; anyone who thinks he's God could be
dangerous. Whatever he says or does, act eternally grateful.
Prepare all year long for a God Boss by:
• Articulating how appreciative you are for the
opportunity to serve in his department in emails and
other appropriate correspondences.
■ Thanking him for his help and guidance on projects.
■ Offering to do him favors or small services.
• Bringing him small gifts, even if they are humorous
tokens and trinkets.
■ Mentioning to his peers how his accomplishments have
driven the department forward.
■ Acknowledging his leadership in written reports and
evaluations of projects.
Before you write these suggestions off as frivolous, consider doing
these things, within reason, for 12 months. If your diagnosis is
correct and your boss thinks he's God, what kind of performance
review do you think you'll receive?
Don't worry about real productivity. You accomplish that for your
own satisfaction and to earn the respect of your peers. A God Boss
will evaluate and qualify you for promotions and raises based on how
faithful a disciple he thinks you are. I guarantee, if he perceives you as
a detractor or ungrateful, no amount of real productivity, efficiency,
or cost savings will bring you into his good graces at performance
review time.
The Machiavellian Boss Review
To Machiavellian Bosses, staff members who step aside in the hall
when she passes, turn and walk in the other direction when she glares,
and routinely put the Machiavellian's name on superior work the staff
members complete will receive high marks on a performance review.
A high mark on a Machiavellian's performance review is a C+ because
she doesn't want anyone outside her domain to see high performance
ratings and come looking for people to promote. Whether or
not the staffers have done anything to promote the achievement of
organizational goals and objectives, promoting the career ambitions
of the Machiavellian translates into job security.
Prepare for your performance review with a Machiavellian Boss
by reviewing everything you have done for the company and make
sure you didn't receive credit for it. If you did receive credit, go into
the performance review and immediately apologize for the mistake
and promise it will never happen again. Act as if you're at a loss to
explain how your name became attached to something the Machiavellian
was obviously responsible for. If you're written up in the company
newsletter for some achievement, demand a retraction in the
following issue.
Men should keep several suits and ties in the office to ensure
color coordination with the Machiavellian. Women must dress to compliment
rather than compete with the Machiavellian. If she comments
about the similarity of your wardrobe, tell her she sets the fashion
trends and emphasize how you watch her closely for guidance. Furthermore,
tell her whatever she wears, drives, eats, or reads should be
required for the entire organizational population.
Understand that everything the Machiavellian tells you regarding,
your performance is twisted through the lens of how it either promotes
or impedes her career. Nod and agree to everything. Don't get
into an "I'm right and you're wrong" thumb wrestling match with a
Machiavellian if you want to go home with two thumbs.
There is but one goal in the Machiavellian's department and that's
the ascending career of the Machiavellian Boss. Make sure everything
you say and do reflects that agenda. Raises are next to impossible
to wrench out of a Machiavellian unless you have really convinced
her your purpose for living is to help her attain the top spot for which
she is predestined.
Prepare all year long for a Machiavellian Boss performance review
by:
■ Articulating how her work is deserving of much more
acclaim from higher up using e-mails and other
appropriate correspondences.
■ Thanking her for allowing you to work on her behalf.
■ Volunteering to take on special projects that promote
her agenda and enhance her image.
■ Selecting wardrobe and decorating your workspace in
ways that suggest allegiance.
■ Mentioning to her peers how her accomplishments
have driven the department forward.
■ Acknowledging the superiority of her leadership in
written reports and evaluations of projects.
Consider doing these things, within reason, for 12 months. If your
diagnosis is correct and your boss is truly Machiavellian, you will receive
the best marks possible on your performance review.
Concern yourself with productivity as a way of accomplishing something
you can give her credit for. You can still be productive as a means
of self-satisfaction and to earn the respect of your peers. However, a
Machiavellian Boss will evaluate and qualify you for promotion, and
raises based on how convinced she is that you support her and do not
compete with her. I guarantee, if she perceives you as a threat or
competitor, no amount of real productivity, efficiency, or cost savings
will bring you into her good graces at performance review time.
The Masochistic Boss Review
Masochists use the performance review to prove what miserable
failures they are. If they were better bosses, they reason, you would
be a better employee. That is true, but not for the reasons they're
citing. Masochists think everything they touch turns to ca-ca and they
don't stop to think about how that might insult you. Don't take it
personally. You didn't have anything to do with creating the
masochist's condition, and there is nothing he can say or do to turn
you into fertilizer.
Wearing something drab might help because it won't draw attention
to clothing. If you wear something bright and cheery, he will
probably notice and go into a downward spiral about what a lousy
dresser he is. He is a terrible dresser, but do you really want to sit and
listen to all that? I'd rather have him tell me I need improvement in
quantity of work, quality of work, work habits, and communication.
Do not carry sharp objects into the masochist's office. Hot coffee
is not advisable. You never know when the urge might strike him to
snatch it out of your hand and pour it into his own lap. Sit with your
eyes down and ever so slightly nod your head in agreement when he
describes the futility of his life. Say nothing. Offer no solutions. Bear
with it as long as you can. You might consider having someone call
you 20 minutes after entering the masochist's office with a fabricated
family emergency providing adequate justification to excuse yourself.
You might be able to get a raise from a Masochistic Boss if you can
convince him it will damage his budget enough to draw a reprimand
from his boss. If he doesn't figure that out on his own, it's up to you to
mention it. As you rush out to visit your brother in the intensive care
unit, pause at the door, turn, and say, "I suppose a raise is out of the
question because it would really bring your boss down hard on you... ."
Then run. The raise should be approved by the time you get back.
Prepare all year long for a Masochistic Boss performance review by:
■ Articulating how he struggles under an excessive workload
that no human being should be expected to manage—use
body language and expressions that slightly mimic the
slumped shoulders and hopeless countenance on his face.
■ Pointing out, in e-mails and face-to-face conversations,
reasons why projects and initiatives imposed on the Masochistic
Boss's department are doomed from the start.
Let him know how sorry you are that he has been put in
this untenable situation.
■ Volunteering to take on special projects and extra
workload from time to time gives you the opportunity to
produce worthwhile work. However, don't rush into the
boss's office rejoicing in the accomplishment.
■ Being prepared to celebrate secretly with your peers.
When and if your Masochistic Boss acknowledges the
success you realized, remain solemn, sigh, and say, "Yeah,
boss, we really got lucky on that one. Don't you wish we
could be so lucky all the time?"
■ Making wardrobe and workspace decorating choices in
ways that avoid exhibiting a dramatic contrast in selfimage
between you and your Masochistic Boss—he should
not feel minimized just being around you.
■ Avoiding overt reassurance with your Masochistic Boss—
when things go terribly wrong, don't tell him it wasn't his
fault. Say instead that it could have happened to anybody
or that anybody could have made a similar mistake, miscalculation,
or misunderstanding.
Consider doing these things, within reason, for 12 months. If your
diagnosis is correct and your boss is a true masochist, you will receive
the best marks possible on your performance review. Like all bosses,
masochists will evaluate and qualify you for promotion and raises based
on how convinced they are that you understand and sympathize with
their dilemmas. Don't avoid productivity altogether; you and your
peers still want to achieve a sense of accomplishment. Just don't celebrate
it as reward for a job well done in front of your Masochistic
Boss. At all times, keep your own interests in perspective. Despite the
skilled ways you play to your Masochistic Boss, you don't want to be
an individual martyr working for a martyred individual.
The Sadistic Boss Review
The performance review is a Sadistic Boss's dream. A legal, sanctioned,
and even required annual session of torture is almost too good
to be true. The Sadistic Boss can hardly contain herself as her employees
absorb the psychological punishment, wail in torment, grimace
in pain, tear their hair out by the fistful, and are forced to come
back at least once a year for more. Sadistic Bosses claim beatings and
the psychological suffering they inflict are related to the achievement
of performance goals and organizational objectives. Yet, nobody knows
better than her long-suffering employees that she gets off on causing
immense pain to the safest, and most vulnerable and available targets.
If you want to get a raise from your Sadistic Boss, claim any
increase in your income will cause you painful tax consequences.
Emphasize the word painful. It's not her money to begin with and, if it
can cause you anguish, it's worth padding the budget.
Setting up your Sadistic Boss for a good performance review
throughout the year requires some acting on your part. Learn to moan
convincingly. You should throw in an anguished cry and plaintive wail
now and then. These can be prerecorded and played back on your
workstation speakers. As long as your Sadistic Boss thinks the sounds
coming from your cubicle are the result of her painfully punitive
workload, she'll like having you around.
Dress as if you sleep in your clothes. If she comments, say flatly
that you haven't slept since she gave you the Mid-range plan to rewrite
again. Wear clothes that are too large so she'll think that you
don't have time to eat. If you're a good makeup artist, make your face
a bit more sallow, apply some bags under your eyes, and hollow out
your cheeks. Pile your office or cubicle with stacks of papers and
reports from floor to ceiling. Leave only enough room for one person
to get in and out. If she thinks you're slaving in there (cue the moans
and wails), she'll leave you alone and go hunt down someone who
looks rested and well fed.
Prepare all year long for a sadistic performance review by:
■ Articulating at every opportunity how you struggle
under an excessive workload—never cross the line and
act angry toward your Sadistic Boss over the excessive
work issue. Instead, act defeated and worn down. I don't
know about you, but I naturally launch into a litany of how
much is on my plate when someone asks, "How are you?"
■ Using body language and expressions that support the grim
descriptions you offer of your circumstances—this also
comes naturally to me. I feel so overwhelmed with my many
and varied tasks at any given time that I don't have to fake
an overworked and underpaid countenance. I don't know
exactly why my heavy burden makes a Sadistic Boss feel
good, but I know enough to give her credit for my struggles,
even if she's not responsible. Attribute a kidney stone to
her work demands. There is a possible seed of truth in it,
but not likely. However, knowing that you're struggling
under an excessive workload while suffering from a kidney
stone will enlarge her sense of satisfaction.
■ In e-mails and face-to-face conversations, pointing out
reasons why projects and initiatives imposed by your Sadistic
Boss are tremendous encumbrances, even if they're
not. It's a sort of dance you do with a sadist. She's happy
with the appearance that her power is sufficient to cause
you discomfort and you don't mind throwing out that
impression if it, in fact, smoothes things out for you in
the real world.
■ Never volunteering to take on special projects and extra
workload—that's taking away her power to control and
abuse you. You must maintain the illusion, whether it is
an illusion or not, that anything she tells you to do could
be the straw that breaks your back.
■ Being prepared to celebrate secretly with your peers. When
and if your Sadistic Boss acknowledges the success you
realized, remain solemn, sigh, and say, "Yeah, boss, that
project took so much time we got backed up on everything
else." If she believes you, she might not immediately
load you up with additional work.
■ Making wardrobe and workspace decorating choices in ways
that avoid exhibiting a lighthearted, carefree existence. Your
work area should be piled high with accumulated stuff,
whether it has anything to do with your current project
or not. A wardrobe motif? In two words: salt mines.
Consider doing these things, within reason, for 12 months. If your
diagnosis is correct and your boss is a sadist, you will receive the best
marks possible on your performance review. As before, don't avoid
productivity altogether; you and your peers still want to achieve a sense
of accomplishment. Just don't expect a job well clone to be welcomed
with time off to catch your breath. The silver lining on the sadist's dark
cloud is the fact that she needs the illusion of power as much as she
needs the actual power. Sadistic Bosses don't generally need to cause
real pain and suffering. If you play your role convincingly enough, a
Sadistic Boss will accept your stellar performance as payment in full.
The Paranoid Boss Review
Your Paranoid Boss will give you an average performance review
by marking all threes on the one-to-five scales. He'll stare at you in
silence as you come in and sit down. Clutching your performance
review in his hand, he'll shut the door, close the blinds, turn up the
radio, and speak in a whisper in case the room is bugged. Some Paranoid
Bosses might even search you for a wire.
He'll tell you the review process is nothing but a veiled attempt to
trick him. But he's too smart to fall for it. He'll say he gave you all
average marks so as not to raise any suspicion with HR, but he knows
what you and your scheming team members are up to.
It's best not to wear all black during your performance review or
at all around a Paranoid Boss. Don't whisper in the office or talk into
your cuff. Don't even take your cell phone with you into the performance
review. If it rings, he'll dive under his desk.
If you want a raise from a Paranoid Boss, take a deep breath,
search the ceiling for hidden cameras, lean close to him and tell him
he's right. Everyone is out to get him and you know who, when, what,
and where. If he'll give you a raise to "cover expenses," promise to
deliver a full report exposing the conspiracy and conspirators. For
your safety, make him agree to transfer you out of his department one
week before the report is due. Once out, you can forget the bogus
report. How is he going to explain rescinding the transfer and raise?
Prepare all year long for a Paranoid Boss's performance review by:
■ Keeping ever
y
thing you do as visible as possible—take
every opportunity to keep all activities in plain sight of
your Paranoid Boss. To the extent you are able, arrange
your working space so that he can observe you from his
office or regular routes of travel.
■ Using body language that features broad, sweeping arm
gestures that suggest openness—as if to assure him that
you, nor anyone else in the department, have nothing to
hide.
■ In e-mails and face-to-face conversations, describing how
you and your fellow team members came up with your
conclusions and what activities led to your results—the
more you can paint a picture for a Paranoid Boss, the
less he will rely on his imagination. That's where the conspiracies
exist, in his fertile imagination.
■ Taking on special projects as if you are working in the
front window at Macy's—giving everyone involved, directly
or peripherally, a brief account of the project's origins
before you move on to a progress report. The contextual
framework within which you place your information can
lead to unsolicited comments coming back at your Paranoid
Boss, indicating an open atmosphere. An open
atmosphere is less threatening than the possibility of covert
operations in dark corridors.
■ Celebrating success openly with your peers—including
your Paranoid Boss at every opportunity. Celebrate in
the office as much as possible so he can't avoid seeing
what you're doing and can't pretend he was excluded.
Even if he doesn't join in the festivities, your message is
clear. You're not hiding anything.
■ Making wardrobe and workspace decorating choices in
ways that provide maximum access and exposure—with
as few walls and partitions as possible. When you meet
with coworkers, do it in the open where the boss can see
you. Do it within earshot if you can. Wave at your Paranoid
Boss during these impromptu meetings and gesture
for him to join you. Your work area should be piled high
with accumulated stuff, whether it has anything to do
with your current project or not.
Consider doing these things, within reason, for 12 months. If your
diagnosis is correct and your boss is paranoid, you will receive the
best marks possible on your performance review. If you have kept
him updated on a daily basis, even with brief, "spontaneous" reports
when there is little to report on, he can't help but feel less threatened.
If you give in to your natural urge to avoid the pain in the corner
office and keep your work, office associations, and comings and goings
to yourself, you're asking for trouble from a Paranoid Boss. As
always, surviving and thriving in the workplace, especially under a paranoid
person, places the responsibility for proactive solutions on your
shoulders. Sure, it's not fair. By now you should realize that little in life
and virtually nothing at work is fair. You haven't been hiding anything,
so why should you jump through hoops to prove as much to your stupid
boss? Because fair is what you make it, that's why.
|