They snatched children from their homes and all the booty
(including bronze and iron) that they carried off on their shoulders
did not fall onto the dark earth, although it was not fastened. They
bore fire on their hair and it did not burn. The villagers, enraged by
the plundering of the Bacchae, rushed to arms. Then, my king,
there was a terrifying sight to behold. The weapons that the villagers
threw did not draw any blood, but when the Bacchae hurled
the thyrsus from their .hands they inflicted wounds on many.
Women routed men-a feat not to be accomplished without the
power of some god. Back they came to where they sallied forth, to
the very streams which the god made gush for them. They washed
their hands of blood and snakes licked the stains from their cheeks.
And so, my lord, receive into the city this god, whoever he is.
He is great in many respects but especially in his reputed gift to
mortals, about which I have heard, the grape, our remedy for pain
and sorrow. With no more wine there could be no more love and no
other pleasure for mankind besides.
Pentheus refuses to listen to the pleas of the messenger and is
determined to rush to arms for an assault on the Bacchae. But the
stranger, Dionysus, finds a way to restrain him by appealing to
Pentheus' basic nature and psychology-in general, the complex neurosis that stems from his repressions, in particular, his prurient
preoccupation with sex and his desire to see the orgies that he
insists are taking place (8 11-6 1) :
DIONYSUS: Would you like to see the women banded together
in the mountains? PENTHEUS: Yes, indeed. I would give a ton of gold for that. DIONYSUS: Why are you driven by such a great desire to see
them? PENTHEUS: Actually, it would pain me to see them drunk. DIONYSUS: Nevertheless you would be pleased to see what' is
painful to you? PENTHEUS: TO be sure, if I watched in silence crouched beneath
the firs, DIONYSUS: But they will track you down, even if you go in
secret. PENTHEUS: Then I shall go openly; what you say is right. DIONYSUS: YOU will undergo the journey, then? Let me lead
you. PENTHEUS: Come, as quickly as possible; I begrudge you this
delay. DIONYSUS: Then dress up in a fine linen robe. PENTHEUS: What is this? Am I to change from a man to a
woman? DIONYSUS: If you are seen there as a man, they will kill you. PENTHEUS: Again, what you say is right. You are like some sage
of long ago. DIONYSUS: Dionysus gives me this inspiration. PENTHEUS: In the garb of a women? But shame holds me back! DIONYSUS: YOU are no longer interested in watching the Maenads
? PENTHEUS: What dress did you say that you would put on me? DIONYSUS: I shall set on your head a long flowing wig. PENTHEUS: And what is the next feature of my outfit? DIONYSUS: A robe that falls to your feet, and a band around your
head. - PENTHEUS: What else will you give me? DIONYSUS: A thyrsus in your hand and a dappled fawnskin
cloak. PENTHEUS: I cannot bring myself to put on the costume of a
woman. DIONYSUS: But if you attack the Bacchae in battle, you will shed
blood. PENTHEUS: This is true; I must first go as a spy. DIONYSUS: TO be sure, it is wiser than to hunt out evil by evil. PENTHEUS: HOW shall I get out of the city without being seen? DIONYSUS: We shall take a deserted route, and I shall lead the
way. PENTHEUS: Anything, ratheruthan have the Bacchae laugh at
me. I shall go into the house and make preparations that are for the
best. DIONYSUS: SO be it, and I am at your side ready for everything. PENTHEUS: I am going inside, I shall either proceed with arms
or follow your instructions. DIONYSUS: Women, this man is ready to be caught in the net.
He will go to the Bacchae and he will pay the penalty with his life.
Dionysus, now do your work; for you are not far away. We shall
exact our retribution. First we shall inflict upon him delirious madness
and drive him out of his wits; in his right mind he would not
want to dress up in the costume of a woman, but once driven from
reason he will put it on. My desire is to make him the laughingstock
of the Thebans as they see him led in a woman's garb through the
city in return for the terrible threats that he uttered before. I go now
to deck out Pentheus in the dress with which he will go down to the
realm of Hades, slaughtered by the hands of his mother. He will
know Dionysus as the son of Zeus and a deity of his own right,
among mankind most dread and most gentle.
The dressing of Pentheus in the garb of the Bacchae suggests
the ceremonial decking out of the sacrificial victim. Pentheus, by
the ritual donning of his costume, falls under the spell and the
power of the god and eventually will be offered up to him.
The
chorus sings of the joys of their worship and the justice of their
triumph over impiety, and at the end of their song Dionysus exerts
final and complete mastery over Pentheus, who is delirious
(9 12-70) : DIONYSUS: Pentheus, I call on you, the one who desires to see
what he should not see and hastens upon what he should not do.
Come forward out of the house, let me behold you dressed in the
garb of a woman, a Bacchic Maenad, about to go as a spy on your
mother and her group. PENTHEUS: I think that I see two suns, and the image of Thebes
with its seven gates appears double. You look like a bull as you lead
me forward, with horns growing out of your head. Were you then an
animal? Now, indeed, you have become a bull. DIONYSUS: The god walks with us; he is on our side although
he was not kindly disposed before. Now you see what you should
see. PENTHEUS: Tell me how I look. Do I not have the carriage of
Ino or my mother, Agave? DIONYSUS: Looking at you I seem to see those very two. But
this lock here that I had fixed under your hairband has fallen out of
place. PENTHEUS: I shook it loose indoors while I was tossing my
head back and forth like a Bacchic reveller. DIONYSUS: Well, we, whose concern is to serve you, shall put it
back in place. Bend your head. PENTHEUS: Fine, you deck me out properly, for I am now dedicated
to you. DIONYSUS: Your belt is loose and the folds of your dress do not
hang straight to your ankles. PENTHEUS: They are not straight at the right foot but here on
the left the dress hangs well at the heel. DIONYSUS: YOU will, I am sure, consider me the best of your
friends, when contrary to your expectation you witness the temperance
of the Bacchae. PENTHEUS: Shall I be more like one of the Bacchae if I hold my
thyrsus in my right or my left hand? DIONYSUS: You should hold it in your right hand, and raise it
and your right foot at the same time. PENTHEUS: Will I be able to lift up on my shoulders Mt. Cithaeron
with its glens full of Bacchae? DIONYSUS: YOU will, if you wish; before your mind was not
sound, but now it is as it ought to be. PENTHEUS: Let us take crowbars, or shall I thrust my shoulder
or my arm under the peaks and crush them with my hands? DIONYSUS: DO not destroy the haunts of the nymphs and the
places where Pan does his piping. PENTHEUS: Your words are right; women must not be overcome
by force; I will hide myself among the firs. DIONYSUS: YOU will find the hiding place that you should, corning
upon the Maenads as a crafty spy. PENTHEUS: Indeed I can see them now in the bushes like birds
held fast in the enticing coils of love. DIONYSUS: Yes, of course, you go on a mission to guard against
this very thing. Maybe you will catch them, if you yourself are not
caught first. PENTHEUS: Take me through the middle of Thebes, for I am the
only man among them who dares this deed. DIONYSUS: You alone bear the burden of toil for this city-you
alone. And so the struggle which must be awaits you. Follow me, I
shall lead you there in safety, but another will lead you back. PENTHEUS: My mother.
DIONYSUS: A spectacle for all.
PENTHEUS: It is for this I am going.
DIONYSUS: YOU will be carried home.
PENTHEUS: What luxury you are suggesting.
DIONYSUSIn: the hands of your mother.
PENTHEUS: YOU insist upon pampering me.
DIONYSUS: Pampering of sorts.
PENTHEUS: Worthy of such deserts I follow you. a Pentheus imagines he will return in a splendid carriage, with
his mother by his side. This terrifying scene is built on more than
this one irony and laden with a multiplicity of ambiguities. How
bitter now appear the earlier taunts of Pentheus against Cadmus
and Tiresias. In his delirium, does Pentheus really see the god in
his true and basic character-a beast? Or does his vision spring
from his own warped interpretation of the bestial nature of the
worship?
A messenger arrives to tell of Pentheus7 death (1043-1152):
MESSENGER: When we had left the town of Thebes behind and
crossed the stream of the Asopus, we made our way up the slopes of
Cithaeron, Pentheus and I (for I followed with my master) and the
stranger who led us to the scene.
First we took a position in a grassy glen, with silent footsteps
and not a word, so that we might see and not be seen. It was a valley
surrounded by cliffs, watered by streams, and shaded by pines;
here Maenads sat, their hands occupied in their joyous tasks. Some
were restoring a crown of ivy on a thyrsus that had lost its foliage,
others, happy as fillies let loose from their painted yokes, were
singing Bacchic hymns in answering refrains. But poor Pentheus,
who could not see this crowd of women, said: "My friend, from
where I stand I am too far away to see these counterfeit Maenads
clearly, but if I climbed up a towering pine on the hill side, I could
properly behold the orgies of the Maenads."
Then and there I saw the stranger do wondrous things. He took
hold of the very top branch of a pine that reached up to the sky and
pulled it down, down, down, to the black earth. And it was bent like
a bow or the curving line of the circle of a wheel. Thus the stranger
grabbed the mountain pine with his hands and bent it to the
ground, a feat no mortal could accomplish. He sat Pentheus on the
topmost branches and let the tree go, sliding it through his hands
until it was upright again, slowly and carefully so that he might not
dislodge him. It towered straight to towering heaven, with our king
perched on top. He could be seen more clearly by the Maenads than he could see them. He was just becoming visible, seated aloft,
when the stranger was no longer to be seen and from heaven a
voice (I imagine that of Dionysus) cried aloud: "0 women, I bring
the man who made a mockery of you and me and our mysteries;
now take vengeance on him." As the voice spoke these words, a
blaze of holy fire flashed between heaven and earth.
The air grew still, every leaf in the wooded glen stood silent,
and no sound of a beast was to be heard. The women had not made
out the voice clearly and they stood up straight and looked around.
He called again and when the daughters of Cadmus understood the
clear command of Bacchus, they rushed forth as swift as doves in
their relentless course, his mother, Agave, her sisters, and all the
Bacchae. With a madness inspired by the breath of the god they
darted over the glen with its streams and rocks. When they saw the
king seated in the pine tree, they first climbed on the rock cliff that
towered opposite and hurled stones at him with all their might and
pelted him with branches of pines. Others hurled the thyrsus
through the air at Pentheus, a pitiable target. But they were unsuc- .
cessful, for the poor wretch sat trapped and helpless, too high for
even their fanaticism. Finally with a lightning force they ripped off
oak branches and tried to use them as levers to uproot the tree. But
when these efforts too were all in vain, Agave exclaimed: "Come, 0 Maenads, stand around the tree in a circle and grab hold of it, so
that we may catch the climbing beast and prevent him from revealing
the secret revels of the god." And they applied a thousand
hands and tore up the tree out of the earth. And from his lofty seat
Pentheus fell hurtling to the ground with endless cries; for he knew
what evil fate was near.
His mother as priestess was the first to begin the slaughter. She
fell on him and he ripped off the band from his hair so that poor
Agave might recognize him and not kill him, and he cried out as he
touched her cheek: "Mother, it is your son, Pentheus, whom you
bore in the home of Echion. Have pity on me for my sins and do not
kill me, your son."
But Agave was not in her right senses; her mouth foamed and
her eyes rolled madly as the god Bacchus held her in his power.
And Pentheus could not reach her. She seized his left arm below
the elbow and placing her foot against the ribs of her ill-fated son,
wrenched his arm out of his shoulder. It was not done through her
own strength but the god made it easy for her hands. From the other
side, Ino clawed and tore at his flesh and Autonoe and the whole
pack converged on him. All shouted together, he moaning with
what breath remained, they screaming in triumph.
One carried an
arm, another a foot with the boot still on; his ribs were stripped clean and they all with blood-drenched hands tossed the flesh of
Pentheus among them like a ball.
His body lies scattered, some pieces under hard rocks, others
in the shady depths of the woods-not easy to find. His mother has
taken his poor head and affixed it on the point of her thyrsus; she
carries it like that of a mountain lion through the depths of Cithaeron,
leaving her sisters and their Maenad bands. She comes
within these walls, exulting in her ill-fated prey and calling on
Bacchus, her partner in the hunt, her comrade in the chase, her
champion of victory, who gave her tears as her reward.
And so I am leaving now, before Agave reaches the palace, to
get away from this misfortune. Temperance and reverence for the
gods are best, the wisest possessions, I believe, that exist for mortals
who will use them.
Agave returns and awakens to the horror of her deed; the concluding
scenes affirm the divine power of Dionysus. There are
serious textual problems in the last section of the play, and a medieval
work, the Christus Patiens, that drew upon Euripides is of
some help-an interesting fact that rivets our attention to the parallels
between Dionysus and Christ.
The pathos and the horror of the butchering of Pentheus have
helped some in their sympathetic view of the rash king as an ascetic
martyr, who is killed in his crusade against the irrational tide of
religious fanaticism. But too much in the makeup of this young man
suggests the myopic psychopath, who, unable to accept human nature
as it is, foolishly tries to suppress it. The basic impulses toward
both the bestial and sublime are terrifyingly and wondrously interrelated;
Dionysus is after all the god of mob fury and religious
ecstasy and anything in between. Was the celebration of his worship
a cry for release from the restraints of civilized society and a
return to the mystic purity and abounding freedom of nature, or was
it merely a deceptive excuse for self-indulgence in an orgy of undisciplined
passion?
The essential characteristics of Dionysiac religion are the possession
by the god of his followers, the rending apart of the sacrificial
animal, and the eating of the raw flesh (omophagy, a kind of
ritual communion, since the god was believed to be present in the
victim). The religious congregation (the holy thiasus) was divided
into groups often with a male leader for each, who played the role
of the god. The Bacchae, or maenads, are the female devotees,
mortal women who become possessed. In mythology they are more
than human, nymphs rather than mere mortals. Their mythological
male counterparts are satyrs, who are, like them, spirits of nature; they, however, are not completely human but part man and part
animal, possessing various attributes of a horse or a goat, for example,
a horse's tail and ears, a goat's beard and horns (although in the
later periods they are often depicted as considerably more humanized).
Satyrs dance and sing and love music; they make wine and
drink it, and they are perpetually in a state of sexual excitement.
One of their favorite sports is to chase maenads through the woods.
Animal skins and garlands are traditional attributes of Bacchic revelers
(although satyrs are usually nude); maenads in particular carry
the thyrsus, a pole wreathed with ivy or vine leaves, pointed at the
top to receive a pine cone. As we have seen, it is a magic wand that
evokes miracles, but if necessary it can be converted into a deadly
weapon.
Sileni also attend Dionysus; they often cannot be distinguished
from satyrs, although some of them are older (papposileni)
and even more lecherous. Yet others are old and wise, like Silenus
himself, the tutor of Dionysus. A story tells how once one of them
was made drunk by adding wine to the water of a spring; when he
was brought to King Midas, this Silenus philosophized that the best
fate for man was not to be born at all, the next best to die as soon as
possible after birth, a typical example of Greek pessimism and wisdom
reminiscent of Solon and HerodotUs. Dionysus and his retinue
are favorite subjects in Greek art.
Dionysus, the male god of vegetation, was, as we should expect,
associated with a fertility-goddess; his mother, Semele, was a
full-fledged earth deity in her own right before she became Hellenized.
The story of Zeus' birth on Crete, with the attendants who
drowned out his infant cries by their frenzied music, suggests contamination
with Dionysiac ritual. Certainly Euripides associates
Bacchic mysticism with the ritual worship of both Rhea and Cybele.
In some accounts Dionysus married Ariadne after she was
deserted by Theseus, another enactment of the union of the male
and female powers of fertility.
Dionysus represents the sap of life, the coursing of the blood
through the veins, the throbbing excitement of nature; thus he is a
god of ecstasy and mysticism. Another myth told about his birth
even more clearly established him in this role.
Zeus mated with his daughter Persephone, who bore a son,
Zagreus, which is another name for Dionysus. Hera in her jealousy
aroused the Titans to attack the child. These monstrous beings,
their faces whitened with chalk, attacked the infant as he was looking
in a mirror, or they beguiled him with toys and cut him to pieces with knives. Afier the murder, the Titans devoured the dismembered
corp~e.B~u t the heart of the infant god was saved and
brought to Zeus by Athena, and Dionysus was born again-swallowed
by Zeus and begotten on Semele. Zeus was angry with the
Titans and destroyed them with his thunder and lightning. But
from their ashes mankind was born.
Surely this is one of the most significant myths in terms of the
philosophy and religious dogma that it provides. By it man is endowed
with a dual nature-a body, gross and evil (since he is
sprung from the Titans), and a soul that is pure and divine (for after
all the Titans had devoured the god). Thus basic religious concepts
(which lie at the root of all mystery religions) are accounted for: sin,
immorality, resurrection, life after death, reward, and punishment.
It is no accident that Dionysus is linked with Orpheus and Demeter
and the message that they preached. He is in his person a resurrection god; the story is told that he went down into the realm of the
dead and brought back his mother, who in this account is usually
given the name Thyone.
In the emotional environment of Dionysiac ecstasy are to be
found the essence and spirit of Greek drama.
|